We may earn a commission if you sign up through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which supplier we recommend. How this site is funded.
Printful owns its print facilities; Printify is a network of third-party printers. Printful gives more consistent print quality at a higher base cost, and its $24.99/month Growth plan becomes free past $12,000 a year in sales. Printify has lower base costs and better international routing, but quality varies by provider. Choose Printful to build a brand, Printify to compete on price.
Key takeaways
- The structural difference — owned factories versus a printer network — drives every other difference between them.
- Printify is cheaper per unit; Printful’s paid plan is cheaper in structure because it stops costing anything once you pass $12k/year.
- Printify quality depends on which print provider you select, so provider testing is a core skill rather than an optional step.
- Both free plans are genuinely usable, so sample orders from both cost under $150 and settle the decision properly.
Printful and Printify are the two suppliers most print-on-demand businesses end up choosing between, and the comparison is genuinely close. They are, however, structurally different companies, and that difference — not the feature lists — is what should decide it for you.
The structural difference that matters
Printful owns and operates its own fulfilment centres. When you place an order, Printful prints it. That gives it direct control over print quality, colour consistency and turnaround, and it means a shirt ordered in March looks like a shirt ordered in September.
Printify is a marketplace of independent print providers. When you place an order, Printify routes it to one of many third-party printers. That gives it a far larger provider network, lower base costs through competition, and better geographic coverage — but quality varies by provider, and two orders of the same product can be fulfilled by two different factories.
Everything else follows from that.
Printful vs Printify at a glance
| Printful | Printify | |
|---|---|---|
| Fulfilment model | Owns its facilities | Network of third-party providers |
| Free plan | Full catalogue, unlimited stores, design and mockup tools | Five stores, unlimited designs |
| Paid plan | Growth, $24.99/mo — up to 33% off products, free past $12k/yr sales | Premium, from $39/mo or from $24.99/mo billed yearly — up to 33% off, ten stores |
| Top tier | Enterprise, custom — managed store, dedicated success manager | Enterprise, custom — unlimited stores, extra discounts |
| Base product cost | Generally higher | Generally lower |
| Print consistency | More consistent | Varies by provider |
| International routing | Good | Better |
| Embroidery & branding | In-house, broader options | Depends on provider |
Pricing
Printful’s “free when you reach $12,000 a year in sales” term on the Growth plan is the more generous structure for a business that is actually working. Printify’s annual billing is the cheaper entry point if you want the discounts immediately. On base product cost, Printify is usually the cheaper of the two, and at volume that difference compounds faster than any subscription saving.
Print quality
This is where the ownership model shows. Printful is the more consistent of the two, and if you are building a brand where a customer might order twice, consistency is worth paying for. Printify’s ceiling is high — its best providers are excellent — but the floor is lower, and you will only know which you have been allocated by ordering samples from the specific provider you intend to use.
Printify does let you choose your print provider rather than accepting the default, and experienced Printify sellers treat provider selection as a core skill rather than a setting. If you are not prepared to do that work, Printful removes the problem for you at a higher unit cost.
Product range
Printful lists around 579 customisable products on its current catalogue — broad, well-photographed and tightly specified. Printify’s catalogue is larger in raw count because it aggregates many providers, which means more variety but also duplicate products at different prices and quality levels. More choice, more decisions.
Printful also offers in-house embroidery, cut-and-sew and branding extras such as inside labels and packing inserts, which are harder to coordinate across a distributed network.
Integrations
Both connect to the platforms that matter: Shopify, Etsy, WooCommerce, eBay, Wix, Squarespace, BigCommerce and Amazon, plus APIs for custom builds. Printful supports a slightly wider set of niche platforms and offers Quick Stores for sellers without a storefront of their own. For the overwhelming majority of sellers, integration availability will not be the deciding factor.
Shipping
Printify’s distributed network gives it an advantage on international orders, because it can often route to a printer in or near the destination country rather than shipping across a border. Printful operates facilities across multiple regions too, but the network effect favours Printify on breadth. If a large share of your orders will land outside your home market, price a realistic basket on both before deciding.
Pros and cons
Printful wins on
- Print consistency order to order
- Embroidery and branding inserts
- Paid plan that stops costing at $12k/yr
- Lower operational effort
Printify wins on
- Lower base product costs
- International routing and coverage
- Larger aggregate catalogue
- Provider choice for cost control
The verdict
Which one should you build on?
Choose Printful if you are building a brand rather than chasing volume, print consistency matters to you, you want embroidery or branding inserts, or you would rather pay more per unit than manage print providers. It is the lower-effort, higher-cost option.
Choose Printify if you are competing on price, selling into varied international markets, or willing to test providers to find the quality you want. It is the higher-effort, lower-cost option, and at scale the cost difference compounds.
For most beginners: open both free accounts and let the physical samples decide. What you are really comparing is a printed garment, and no comparison article substitutes for holding one.
Test both before you commit a catalogue
Both free plans let you set up and order samples without a subscription. Order your three likely hero products from each — and on Printify, from two different providers — for under $150 total.
Start with PrintfulStart with Printify
Affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no cost to you.
Frequently asked questions
Is Printful or Printify cheaper?
Printify is generally cheaper on base product cost, because its providers compete with one another. Printful’s paid plan is cheaper in structure, since Growth becomes free once you pass $12,000 a year in sales while Printify’s Premium remains a recurring cost.
Can you use Printful and Printify together?
Yes. Many sellers run both, using one supplier for products where it has the better price or quality and the other elsewhere. Most store platforms allow both apps to be installed simultaneously, with each product assigned to a specific supplier.
Which has better print quality, Printful or Printify?
Printful is more consistent because it prints in its own facilities. Printify’s quality depends on which print provider fulfils the order, and its best providers match Printful while its weaker ones do not.
Do Printful and Printify both have affiliate programs?
Yes. Printify pays 5% of referred customers’ spend for 12 months with a 90-day cookie, run through PartnerStack. Printful’s affiliate terms specify a 12-month affiliate period per referred customer, a 30-day cookie, PayPal payouts and a $25 minimum withdrawal.
Which is better for beginners?
Printful is the simpler starting point because it removes print-provider selection from the equation, so there is less to get wrong. Printify suits beginners who are price-sensitive and willing to order samples from several providers before listing products.
Related guides
How to start a print-on-demand business with AI
The full build, from niche validation through to pricing for a margin worth having.
The best AI tools for POD designs
Generation, upscaling, background removal and the file specs printing actually requires.